You are here

Comparative data of the clinic, diagnosis and course of drug-sensitive and drug-resistant tuberculosis among children and adolescents in the Republic of kazakhstan

Log in or Register to download article file.
Keywords
#tuberculosis #mdrtb #rifampicin #resistance #sensitive
Information about authors

Bekembaeva Gulbadan Sabitovna, Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor of the Department of Phthisiology

NJSC "Astana Medical University"

(010000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Nur-Sultan, Beibitshilik street, 49a, e-mail: gbekem@mail.ru)

Tashpulatova Fatima Kudratovna

Tashkent Pediatric Medical University

(100140, Republic of Uzbekistan, Tashkent, Bogishamol str., 223)

Tursynali Sagynysh, intern doctor

NJSC "Astana Medical University"

(010000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Nur-Sultan, Beibitshilik street, 49a, e-mail: saghynysh.t@gmail.com)

Tashimov Almas Mynbaevich, intern doctor

NJSC "Astana Medical University"

(010000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Nur-Sultan, Beibitshilik street, 49a, e-mail: tashimov.almas@gmail.com)

Introduction

Drug-resistant tuberculosis is one of the global problems of modern phthisiology. Of particular concern is the fact that children from contact with tuberculosis patients often become infected with MBT, the spectrum of drug resistance to anti-TB drugs in which fully or partially (in 69.9% of cases) coincides with the spectrum of resistance at the source of infection. Children from bacillary foci to reach 12-14 years in 30-40% of cases are infected with MBT (King OI 2001). At present, as noted by a number of authors (Aksenova K.I., et al. 2015 and others), there are no significant trends towards a decrease in the incidence of children from foci of tuberculosis infection, despite the high coverage of children with preventive measures - vaccination, BCG revaccination and chemoprophylaxis ... The tasks of identifying the causes that contribute to the formation and development of drug-resistant forms of tuberculosis in children and studying the features of the clinical manifestations and course of drug-resistant tuberculosis remain relevant. Knowledge of the risk factors for the onset and characteristics of clinical manifestations of tuberculosis caused by MBT with drug resistance to anti-TB drugs will increase the effectiveness of prevention, detection and treatment of this disease.

Goal

To study the features of the clinical course of drug-resistant and sensitive tuberculosis in children and adolescents.

Materials and methods of research

Comprehensively examined 120 children and adolescents, from tuberculosis contact, treated in the clinic of the anti-tuberculosis dispensary in Kazakhstan for drug-resistant tuberculosis of the respiratory system. The control group consisted of 117 newly diagnosed patients with preserved sensitivity of mycobacterium tuberculosis to anti-tuberculosis drugs, who were also in hospital. 

In both groups, there were slightly more girls on treatment 62 (51.7%) and 61 (52.1%) than boys 58 (48.3%) and 56 (47.8%) aged 1-17 years respectively. By age, they were distributed in the main group as follows: children aged 6-12 years - 3 cases each (2.5%), (6 years-3, 8 years-3, 10 - 3, 11 - 3, 12 years - 3 children); at the age of 13-14 years - 18 (15.0%) and adolescents from 15-17 years old made up the largest group - 87 (72.5%) people. We divided children and adolescents for the first time into four age groups: young children from 0-3 years old - 21 (17.9%), younger preschool children - from 4-7 years old - 11 (9.4%), prepubertal children - from 8-14 years old - 32 (27.3%) and adolescents - from 15-17 years old - 53 (45.3%). That is, there were no young children (from 0-3 years old) in the main group, and among patients with newly diagnosed tuberculosis, such were 17.9%. The largest number of cases in both groups were adolescents from 15-17 years old - 72.5% and 45.3%, respectively. Urban children were in the majority in both groups - 71 (59.2%) and 95 (81.2%), respectively, rural children - 49 (40.8%) and 22 (18.8%). That is, the risk of developing tuberculosis in urban settings is higher due to closer and more frequent contact with sick bacteria-releasing bacteria.

Results

 The majority of children and adolescents with drug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) were detected when they applied to various institutions of the general medical network - in 68 (56.7%) cases, in the control group they were detected in most cases - 79 (67.5% ) during a routine examination. When contacting various medical institutions with breast complaints, 38 (32.5%) children were identified. Tuberculin diagnostics revealed that hyperergic reactions (the size of the tuberculin reaction 15-21 mm) to the introduction of tuberculin were observed in 58 (48.3%) children and adolescents with drug-resistant tuberculosis, normergic (6-14 mm) - in 62 (51.7 %), that is, it can be noted that this contingent responded adequately to the tuberculin Mantoux reaction with 2 TE PPD-L. Patients with a newly diagnosed process in 112 (96.6%) cases reacted positively to the Mantoux test with 2 TE. Thus, a hyperergic reaction was observed in 45 (38.5%) patients with newly diagnosed respiratory tuberculosis. A positive reaction (from 5-10 mm) was noted in 39 (33.3%) patients, normal (11-14 mm) in 33 (28.2%), and only in 3 (2.6%) patients a reaction to the introduction of tuberculin was negative. Looking ahead, it can be noted that these children were found to have common, generalized processes that could lead to a decrease in general immunity, in 2 children out of three leading to a lethal outcome of the disease. 

    Comparative analysis of post-vaccination signs of BCG in both groups showed that they were absent in 25 (20.8%) patients with MDR-TB, 49 (40.8%) patients had one post-vaccination scar, 46 (38.3%) %) adolescents. 

    Consequently, in 79.1% of cases, the vaccination period was more than 5 years. It should be noted that 50% of children and adolescents with drug-resistant tuberculosis (main group) who did not have post-vaccination scars developed the most severe forms of tuberculosis, with a tendency to generalization and complications in the form of bronchial tuberculosis (62.9%), with an outcome in cicatricial stenosis and deformity, concomitant tuberculous pleurisy, tuberculosis of the tongue and pulmonary hemorrhage (47.7%). 

    Most of the newly diagnosed patients (control group) (89.7%) were vaccinated with BCG vaccine in maternity hospitals, however, 21 (17.9%) patients did not develop a post-vaccination scar, and 12 (10.2%) sick young children did not develop at all. were not vaccinated due to the lack of BCG vaccine in the first year of life of these children. 

    58 (49.5%) newly diagnosed patients had one post-vaccination scar of BCG, of which 12 (20.7%) children under 6 years old who did not receive the first revaccination, the remaining 46 (79.3%) children were more older, they were not revaccinated in connection with the tube. infection. Twenty-seven (23.1%) children and adolescents with tuberculosis had two BCG scars. Of 53 adolescents aged 15-17 years, 31 (58.5%) patients did not receive the second revaccination. Thus, the majority of adolescents with respiratory tuberculosis (58.5%) were not revaccinated with BCG, and young children (28.2%) of the control group were not vaccinated with BCG, which contributed to infection and further development of the disease. 

    Analysis of information on the presence of contact among patients with MDR TB showed that 40 (33.3%) children and adolescents were from foci of death from drug-resistant forms of tuberculosis. From close family contact with patients with MDR, patients where the mother was ill, 34 (28.3%) children were identified, the father - 25 (20.8%), brother or sister - 30 (25.0%) children. No tuberculosis contact with a patient with tuberculosis was established in 18 (15.0%) cases, family contact was noted in 12 (10.0%), with a classmate and a teacher in 3 (2.5%) cases, respectively. 

Thus, the vast majority of patients had close family contact with a patient with MDR-TB in 89 (74.2%) cases, which led to the emergence and development of drug-resistant forms of tuberculosis in them. Among the newly diagnosed patients, tuberculosis contact was denied or it was not established in 62 (53.0%) cases. 26 (22.2%) children and adolescents had close family contact with a sick bacteria-releasing agent. From family contact, 19 (16.2%) children fell ill, with a teacher, a neighbor - 2 (1.7%) teenagers. In 9 (7.7%) children and adolescents with pulmonary tuberculosis, contact with the patient was the most ominous - the family center of death of a patient with multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. 

More than half of the patients 66 (56.4%) were infected with MBT in the period from 1 to 3 years, however, only 34 (29.0%) sick children received chemoprophylactic treatment, the remaining 83 children (71.0%) who needed preventive treatment, in order to prevent infection and the development of the disease, did not receive it. That is, the selection among children and adolescents into the “risk” group for tuberculosis was not carried out at the proper level. 

    During the first year of infection, 51 (43.6%) patients were identified by fluorography. When a tuberculous process was detected by fluorography and in the absence of bacterial excretion, the differential diagnostic algorithm was carried out in 79 (67.5%) patients, and in 38 (32.5%) patients, it was not carried out, since the specific etiology of the disease was not in doubt. 

Upon admission to the hospital, after a thorough examination of children and adolescents, it was determined that patients in the main group (120 with MDR-TB) had a variety of pronounced clinical symptoms with signs of tuberculous intoxication (71.4%) and complaints of cough (50.6 %). Catarrhal phenomena in the lungs were determined in 36.9% of children and adolescents. 

Patients of the control group (117 - newly diagnosed patients) in 40.0% of cases complained of cough with the release of mucopurulent or purulent sputum. An increase in body temperature to febrile and subfebrile figures was noted in 31.0% of cases, weight loss and loss of appetite - in 37.0%, weakness - in 38.0%, night sweats - in 26.0%, chest pain - in 19.0%, shortness of breath during exercise - in 18.0% of cases. Catarrhal phenomena in the lungs in the form of hard or weakened breathing and the presence of various wheezing were detected in 12.5%, which was significantly lower than in MDR-TB patients (p <0.05). The above complaints were presented by patients, who were mainly admitted to the hospital in a state of moderate severity (43.0%) and severe (10.3%) condition. The contingent of children and adolescents who were admitted in a satisfactory condition did not generally present complaints, although 82.4% of them had one or another concomitant pathology.

Discussion

The majority of children and adolescents with drug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) were detected when they applied to various institutions of the general medical network - in 68 (56.7%) cases, in the control group they were detected in most cases - 79 (67.5% ) during a routine examination. When contacting various medical institutions with breast complaints, 38 (32.5%) children were identified. Tuberculin diagnostics revealed that hyperergic reactions (the size of the tuberculin reaction 15-21 mm) to the introduction of tuberculin were observed in 58 (48.3%) children and adolescents with drug-resistant tuberculosis, normergic (6-14 mm) - in 62 (51.7 %), that is, it can be noted that this contingent responded adequately to the tuberculin Mantoux reaction with 2 TE PPD-L. Patients with a newly diagnosed process in 112 (96.6%) cases reacted positively to the Mantoux test with 2 TE. Thus, a hyperergic reaction was observed in 45 (38.5%) patients with newly diagnosed respiratory tuberculosis. A positive reaction (from 5-10 mm) was noted in 39 (33.3%) patients, normal (11-14 mm) in 33 (28.2%), and only in 3 (2.6%) patients a reaction to the introduction of tuberculin was negative. Looking ahead, it can be noted that these children were found to have common, generalized processes that could lead to a decrease in general immunity, in 2 children out of three leading to a lethal outcome of the disease. 

Comparative analysis of post-vaccination signs of BCG in both groups showed that they were absent in 25 (20.8%) patients with MDR-TB, 49 (40.8%) patients had one post-vaccination scar, 46 (38.3%) %) adolescents. 

    Consequently, in 79.1% of cases, the vaccination period was more than 5 years. It should be noted that 50% of children and adolescents with drug-resistant tuberculosis (main group) who did not have post-vaccination scars developed the most severe forms of tuberculosis, with a tendency to generalization and complications in the form of bronchial tuberculosis (62.9%), with an outcome in cicatricial stenosis and deformity, concomitant tuberculous pleurisy, tuberculosis of the tongue and pulmonary hemorrhage (47.7%). 

    Most of the newly diagnosed patients (control group) (89.7%) were vaccinated with BCG vaccine in maternity hospitals, however, 21 (17.9%) patients did not develop a post-vaccination scar, and 12 (10.2%) sick young children did not develop at all. were not vaccinated due to the lack of BCG vaccine in the first year of life of these children. 

    58 (49.5%) newly diagnosed patients had one post-vaccination scar of BCG, of which 12 (20.7%) children under 6 years old who did not receive the first revaccination, the remaining 46 (79.3%) children were more older, they were not revaccinated in connection with the tube. infection. Twenty-seven (23.1%) children and adolescents with tuberculosis had two BCG scars. Of 53 adolescents aged 15-17 years, 31 (58.5%) patients did not receive the second revaccination. Thus, the majority of adolescents with respiratory tuberculosis (58.5%) were not revaccinated with BCG, and young children (28.2%) of the control group were not vaccinated with BCG, which contributed to infection and further development of the disease. 

Analysis of information on the presence of contact among patients with MDR TB showed that 40 (33.3%) children and adolescents were from foci of death from drug-resistant forms of tuberculosis. From close family contact with patients with MDR, patients where the mother was ill, 34 (28.3%) children were identified, the father - 25 (20.8%), brother or sister - 30 (25.0%) children. No tuberculosis contact with a patient with tuberculosis was established in 18 (15.0%) cases, family contact was noted in 12 (10.0%), with a classmate and a teacher in 3 (2.5%) cases, respectively. 

Thus, the vast majority of patients had close family contact with a patient with MDR-TB in 89 (74.2%) cases, which led to the emergence and development of drug-resistant forms of tuberculosis in them. Among the newly diagnosed patients, tuberculosis contact was denied or it was not established in 62 (53.0%) cases. 26 (22.2%) children and adolescents had close family contact with a sick bacteria-releasing agent. From family contact, 19 (16.2%) children fell ill, with a teacher, a neighbor - 2 (1.7%) teenagers. In 9 (7.7%) children and adolescents with pulmonary tuberculosis, contact with the patient was the most ominous - the family center of death of a patient with multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. 

More than half of the patients 66 (56.4%) were infected with MBT in the period from 1 to 3 years, however, only 34 (29.0%) sick children received chemoprophylactic treatment, the remaining 83 children (71.0%) who needed preventive treatment, in order to prevent infection and the development of the disease, did not receive it. That is, the selection among children and adolescents into the “risk” group for tuberculosis was not carried out at the proper level. 

During the first year of infection, 51 (43.6%) patients were identified by fluorography. When a tuberculous process was detected by fluorography and in the absence of bacterial excretion, the differential diagnostic algorithm was carried out in 79 (67.5%) patients, and in 38 (32.5%) patients, it was not carried out, since the specific etiology of the disease was not in doubt. 

Upon admission to the hospital, after a thorough examination of children and adolescents, it was determined that patients in the main group (120 with MDR-TB) had a variety of pronounced clinical symptoms with signs of tuberculous intoxication (71.4%) and complaints of cough (50.6 %). Catarrhal phenomena in the lungs were determined in 36.9% of children and adolescents. 

Patients of the control group (117 - newly diagnosed patients) in 40.0% of cases complained of cough with the release of mucopurulent or purulent sputum. An increase in body temperature to febrile and subfebrile figures was noted in 31.0% of cases, weight loss and loss of appetite - in 37.0%, weakness - in 38.0%, night sweats - in 26.0%, chest pain - in 19.0%, shortness of breath during exercise - in 18.0% of cases. Catarrhal phenomena in the lungs in the form of hard or weakened breathing and the presence of various wheezing were detected in 12.5%, which was significantly lower than in MDR-TB patients (p <0.05). The above complaints were presented by patients, who were mainly admitted to the hospital in a state of moderate severity (43.0%) and severe (10.3%) condition. The contingent of children and adolescents admitted in a satisfactory condition did not generally present complaints, although 82.4% of them had one or another concomitant pathology.

Conclusion

1. The clinical picture of drug-resistant and newly diagnosed respiratory tuberculosis differ in the methods of detection, the course of the disease and the presence of concomitant pathology, complications of tuberculosis, as well as laboratory parameters. In patients with drug-resistant tuberculosis, a protracted course of the disease leads to chronicity of concomitant pathology, the severity of clinical symptoms. Decay cavities were found significantly more often in patients of the main group. 

2. Multidrug resistance was identified in 91.7% of MDR-TB patients. Among the reserve drugs, drug resistance was determined to prothionamide (Pt) in 88.3% of cases, to the injectable drug capreomycin (Cm) - in 43.3%, ofloxacin (Of) - in 12.5%, amikacin (Amik) - in 23.3% and least of all, drug resistance to cycloserine (Cs) and kanamycin was determined - in 10.0% and 7.5% of cases, respectively. 

3. In the overwhelming majority of cases (92.5%), patients with MDR-TB had a complicated course of the tuberculous process. At the same time, the disintegration of lung tissue was noted in 82.5% of patients, tuberculous lesion of the bronchus - in 17.5%, seeding - in 70.0%, pulmonary hemorrhages - in 8.2%, spontaneous pneumothorax - in 1.7% of patients.

References

1. Aksenova VA et al. Federal clinical guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of respiratory tuberculosis in children // Med. alliance. –2015. - No. 3. - P. 10-23 

2. Aksenova V.A., Klevno N.I., Kavtarashvili S.M., Kazakov A.V., Pakhlavonova A.D. The focus of tuberculosis infection as a risk of developing multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in children. Tuberculosis and lung disease. 2018; 96 (1): 11-17 

3. Madasova VG Drug-resistant tuberculosis in children (causes, features of clinical manifestations and course): Dis. ... Cand. honey. sciences. - M., 2010. 

4. Guidelines for the management of patients with latent tuberculosis infection. WHO / HTM / TB / 2015.01 // www.who.int / tb. 

5. Order of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 04/25/2011. for No. 218 "On some issues in the fight against TB", Appendix 3 "Instruction for the management of patients with multidrug and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis in anti-tuberculosis organizations" 

6. Order of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 404 of June 17, 2011 "On measures to improve measures to combat tuberculosis in the Republic of Kazakhstan" 

7. Decree of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 21, 2007. No. 1263 "On measures to protect the population from tuberculosis in the Republic of Kazakhstan"

8. State program for the development of health care of the Republic of Kazakhstan "Salamatty Kazakhstan" for 2011-2015. 

9. Cohen T., Murray M. Modeling epidemics of multidrug-resistant M. tuberculosis of heterogeneous fitness // Nature. Med. - 2004.- Vol.10.- P.1117-1120. 

10. World Health Organization. Guidelines for Surveillance of Drug Resistance in Tuberculosis. - WHO, Geneva, 2003. - P.71. 

11. Ten MB Medical and social characteristics of patients with drug-resistant tuberculosis: author. dis. ... Cand. medical sciences. - M., 2007.-29s.

Top